BEE ownership is the heaviest single element on the generic scorecard at 25 points, and a priority element with a sub-minimum. It measures how much of your business black people really own: their votes, their share of the profits and how much of their shares they have paid for. It is also where structures get complicated and where the risk of fronting is highest. This page explains what the agency measures and the common kinds of deal. One request reaches B-BBEE consultants and verification agencies who quote you directly; for the deal itself you need an attorney and tax advice.
What the agency measures
- Voting rights: the share of votes black people hold.
- Economic interest: their share of dividends and other returns.
- Net value: how much of their shares is actually paid off, which falls if the deal is funded by debt that is not yet repaid.
- Extra points for black women, black designated groups (youth, people with disabilities, the unemployed, people in rural areas, military veterans) and new entrants.
The sub-minimum matters: miss it and the level drops by one.
Common kinds of deal
A direct sale of shares to black individuals or a black-owned company. An employee share ownership plan (ESOP), where staff hold shares through a trust. Broad-based ownership schemes and community trusts. Many deals are vendor financed: the seller lends the buyer the money and dividends repay the loan, which is why net value builds up over time. Multinationals that cannot sell local shares may use equity equivalent programmes approved by the dtic. A major B-BBEE transaction above the threshold must be registered with the B-BBEE Commission.
Fronting is a crime
Black people as names only, shareholders with no real rights or returns, or misrepresenting who owns what is fronting, a criminal offence under the amended Act. So is knowingly giving false information to an agency. Agencies read shareholder agreements, interview shareholders and check where dividends go. Never accept a structure built to look good on paper. Warning signs include shareholders who cannot say what they own, dividends that flow back to the seller, and agreements that let the old owners take the shares back at will. The B-BBEE Commission investigates complaints.
Who to talk to
A B-BBEE consultant can model how a deal would score and how net value grows. An attorney drafts the agreements and a tax practitioner advises on the tax side; we give no legal or tax advice. The verification agency then measures the result. A gap analysis first tells you whether ownership is the right place to spend.
What to put in your request
- Your annual turnover and current shareholding
- Any existing black shareholders and their percentages
- The kind of deal you are considering: sale, ESOP or trust
- How the deal would be funded, including vendor finance
- Whether you already have an attorney and tax adviser
B-BBEE Ownership Structures for small firms, contractors, factories, farms and more
- Small businesses and start-ups: owner-run firms weighing whether black ownership would lift their deemed level
- Contractors and built environment firms: contractors bringing in black partners to meet tender and sector code needs
- Factories and engineering works: family-owned factories setting up an ESOP for long-serving employees
- Mines and mining suppliers: mining suppliers and contractors with community trusts and ownership expectations
- Retailers, wholesalers and distributors: distributors and franchise groups selling a stake to a black-owned investor
- Professional, ICT and financial firms: firms of accountants, engineers or consultants admitting black partners
- Transport, logistics and service contractors: logistics and fleet companies with vendor-financed black ownership deals
- Farms, packhouses and agri-processors: farms and packhouses with worker trusts measured under AgriBEE
- Hotels, lodges and tour operators: lodges and hotels with community or employee ownership schemes
Frequently asked questions
Will you structure our ownership deal?
Does an ESOP count as black ownership?
Why is our net value score low when the shares were sold?
Does a small business need an ownership deal?
B-BBEE Ownership Structures by province and city
- Johannesburg
- Pretoria
- Centurion
- Midrand
- Sandton
- Randburg
- Roodepoort
- Krugersdorp
- Randfontein
- Germiston
- Boksburg
- Benoni
- Kempton Park
- Alberton
- Vanderbijlpark
- Vereeniging
- Durban
- Pinetown
- Pietermaritzburg
- Richards Bay
- Newcastle
- Ladysmith
- Gqeberha (Port Elizabeth)
- East London
- Kariega (Uitenhage)
- Mthatha
- Cape Town
- Bellville
- Paarl
- Stellenbosch
- George
- Worcester
- eMalahleni (Witbank)
- Middelburg
- Secunda
- Mbombela (Nelspruit)
- Rustenburg
- Brits
- Klerksdorp
- Potchefstroom
- Mahikeng
- Polokwane
- Tzaneen
- Kimberley
- Upington
- Bloemfontein
- Welkom
- Sasolburg
