Going into a verification blind is an expensive way to learn your level. A B-BBEE gap analysis, also called a pre-assessment, is a mock scorecard a consultant builds from your own figures before the agency arrives. It shows your likely level, where each element falls short, which gaps cost least to close and which documents are missing. Firms usually do one before their first verification, after a disappointing result, before a big tender, or when they grow from EME to QSE or from QSE to generic. Send one request and consultants who work in your area quote you directly.
What goes into the mock scorecard
The first question is your size class: an EME, or a QSE that is at least 51% black owned, may only need an affidavit. Otherwise the consultant takes your measurement period, usually the last financial year, and scores each element as an agency would: ownership, management control, skills development, enterprise and supplier development, and socio-economic development. For each one you see the likely points, the target and the gap. The analysis also checks the priority elements: on the generic scorecard, missing the 40% sub-minimum on ownership, skills development or ESD drops your level by one, and QSEs must meet ownership plus one other priority element.
The costed plan
A list of gaps is only half the job. A useful pre-assessment ranks the fixes by points for each rand and by time. Collecting certificates from compliant suppliers you already use often costs nothing. Supplier development, enterprise development and SED are measured against net profit after tax, skills spend against payroll, so each step can carry a rand figure. Learnerships and YES placements take 12 months. Ownership changes take months and need an attorney and tax advice. Ask for the plan to show your likely level with and without each step.
The evidence list
Many verifications are delayed or lose points because evidence is missing, not because the work was not done. A gap analysis should end with a document list per element: financial statements, the shareholder register and agreements, payroll and employment equity reports, the WSP and ATR, training invoices and attendance registers, supplier certificates and affidavits, and ESD and SED agreements with proof of payment. Points you cannot prove do not count, so this list is often worth as much as the score itself.
How it differs from a verification
A pre-assessment is done by a consultant, not by your verification agency, because an agency must stay independent of the entities it verifies. The result is an estimate. The agency reads your evidence for itself, and its verification sets the level on your certificate. Be careful with anyone who guarantees the mock level; a careful consultant marks items as likely, doubtful or not yet proven.
What to put in your request
- Your annual turnover and black ownership percentage
- When your financial year ends
- Your sector and any sector code you think applies
- Your last certificate and verification report, if any
- The level you need and the date you need it by
B-BBEE Gap Analysis and Pre-Assessment for small firms, contractors, factories, farms and more
- Small businesses and start-ups: a firm crossing R10 million that wants to know its first QSE result
- Contractors and built environment firms: a contractor checking its likely level before a round of municipal tenders
- Factories and engineering works: a component maker finding gaps before a customer's supplier review
- Mines and mining suppliers: a mining supplier testing its scorecard before a contract renewal
- Retailers, wholesalers and distributors: a wholesaler checking preferential procurement and supplier certificates
- Professional, ICT and financial firms: an ICT firm testing its score on the ICT sector code
- Transport, logistics and service contractors: a freight company over R50 million checking the generic priority elements
- Farms, packhouses and agri-processors: a packhouse testing its AgriBEE score before exporters ask
- Hotels, lodges and tour operators: a guesthouse group checking where it stands under the tourism code
Frequently asked questions
When should I do a gap analysis?
Is a gap analysis worth it for a small business?
Will the agency give me the same score?
Do you do the pre-assessment yourselves?
B-BBEE Gap Analysis and Pre-Assessment by province and city
- Johannesburg
- Pretoria
- Centurion
- Midrand
- Sandton
- Randburg
- Roodepoort
- Krugersdorp
- Randfontein
- Germiston
- Boksburg
- Benoni
- Kempton Park
- Alberton
- Vanderbijlpark
- Vereeniging
- Durban
- Pinetown
- Pietermaritzburg
- Richards Bay
- Newcastle
- Ladysmith
- Gqeberha (Port Elizabeth)
- East London
- Kariega (Uitenhage)
- Mthatha
- Cape Town
- Bellville
- Paarl
- Stellenbosch
- George
- Worcester
- eMalahleni (Witbank)
- Middelburg
- Secunda
- Mbombela (Nelspruit)
- Rustenburg
- Brits
- Klerksdorp
- Potchefstroom
- Mahikeng
- Polokwane
- Tzaneen
- Kimberley
- Upington
- Bloemfontein
- Welkom
- Sasolburg
